In August 2025, the last apartment built at the Residences at 66 High Street in Guilford sold for $5.45 million. It is the only unit on the top floor of the Chittenden building. It has a screened porch facing the salt marsh and Long Island Sound, a great room large enough for a grand piano, and more than 4,000 square feet of space designed by David Scott Parker Architects. In the town's condo statistics it counts as one sale, the same as a 605-square-foot one-bedroom.
That single closing goes a long way toward explaining the most surprising line in Guilford's 2026 market data. SmartMLS reports a townhouse and condo median of $369,000 for January through October 2026, down 32.9% from $550,000 over the same months of 2025. Over that same stretch, the single-family median rose 5.6% to $670,750. If you're comparing Shoreline towns and looking at condos, that headline makes it look like Guilford condos got cheaper. The individual sales on either side of it point to a change in the mix of units. SmartMLS counts townhouses and condos as one category, and "condo" below means that combined category.
Who Was in the 2025 Pool
Guilford is a small condo market. Through October 2025 it recorded 43 townhouse and condo closings, at an average price of $840,435. Several of those closings were homes that rarely come up for sale in any town.
Besides the 66 High Street penthouse, Eagleview at Guilford on Whitfield Street sold its unit #3, a new-construction townhouse of 3,973 square feet, for $2.1 million in June 2025. In September 2025, a new townhome at Village on State, the 25-unit community on Village Circle off State Street, closed at $811,864.
With 43 closings, one $5.45 million sale adds about $110,000 to the average all by itself. Take it out and the January-through-October 2025 average would be close to $730,700. A median can't be pulled around by one sale like that. What moves a median is a change in which homes fill the middle of the list, and 2025's middle included new construction priced in the $800,000s and above.
Who Was in the 2026 Pool
Through October 2026, Guilford had more condo closings than a year earlier, 49 against 43, and the average fell to $479,325. The 2026 sales below come from older complexes with smaller floor plans.
| Sale | Built | Size | Price | Closed |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 66 High Street penthouse | 2024 | about 4,236 sq ft | $5,450,000 | Aug. 7, 2025 |
| Eagleview, 405 Whitfield St. #3 | New construction | 3,973 sq ft | $2,100,000 | June 2025 |
| Village on State, 36 Village Circle | New construction | 2,197 sq ft | $811,864 | Sept. 5, 2025 |
| River Colony #7 | 1977 | 894 sq ft | $280,000 | May 11, 2026 |
| River Colony #31 | Resale | 605 sq ft | $250,000 | July 1, 2026 |
| 274 Church Street #8C | Resale | 1,206 sq ft | $265,000 | Aug. 19, 2026 |
| River Colony #12 | 1977 | 894 sq ft | $325,000 | Oct. 20, 2026 |
River Colony is a 59-unit complex from the late 1970s, and some of its units have water views. Over 2026 it supplied a steady run of sales between $250,000 and $325,000. Sales like these sit near or below this year's $369,000 median. A pool weighted toward them, without a $5.45 million penthouse, produces a lower median even where individual units held their value.
October shows the same effect at a smaller scale. That month, 10 Guilford condos closed at a median of $172,500. In October 2025, three closed at a median of $821,259. SmartMLS's own footnote warns that percent changes "can sometimes look extreme due to small sample size." A 79% monthly drop based on three sales against ten describes those thirteen sales and very little else.
Where One Complex Can Be Tracked, Prices Rose
Village on State is the clearest way to separate composition from value, because similar new townhomes in this one community have been listed and sold since 2024. The townhome that closed at $811,864 in September 2025 was first listed at $809,900 in July 2024. A Village on State unit listed this year went under contract at $909,900. Another, still under construction, is asking $989,900.
The community has two-bedroom townhomes of more than 2,000 square feet with garages and full basements, within walking distance of the Guilford Green, the library, and the shops and restaurants downtown. Within that one community, the 2026 numbers are higher than the 2024 numbers. The town median and this community moved in opposite directions, which is what a shift in the mix of sales looks like.
Time and Leverage Are Where Condos Really Differ
The price comparison between Guilford condos and houses is distorted by the mix of sales. The pace comparison holds up better, and it matters more to someone deciding how to shop.
From January through October 2026, Guilford condos took 82 days on average to go from listing to sale, against 29 for single-family homes. Condo sellers received 99.4% of list price on average, while single-family sellers received 103.1%. In October alone the gap was wider. Condos took 103 days and sold at 91.5% of list, while houses took 24 days and sold at 103.7%. At the end of October there were 20 condos for sale, 3.9 months of supply, compared with 3.2 months for single-family homes.
For a buyer, that means a single-family purchase in Guilford this year has typically involved paying over asking within a few weeks. Condo buyers have had more time to decide, and in recent months they have usually paid less than the asking price. New construction runs on its own schedule, because the builder is selling while the homes go up. The Village on State townhome that closed in September 2025 was on the market for 14 months first.
Pricing a Guilford Condo by Its Complex
The complexes are different enough that the town median tells you little about any one listing. Compare a unit with recent sales in its own complex, or with complexes of the same age and type.
- River Colony: built in the late 1970s, 59 units, one-bedroom and two-bedroom layouts, some with water views. 2026 sales fell between $250,000 and $325,000.
- Cedar Crest: a 10-unit community at 2514 Boston Post Road with one-level units built in 1985.
- The Residences at 66 High Street: built starting in 2016, with marsh and Sound views, a pool, a fitness center, a fire pit and a dog park. It is near the water but not directly on it.
- Village on State: 25 new two-bedroom townhomes near the Green, now trading in the $900,000s.
- Eagleview at Guilford: newer, larger townhomes on Whitfield Street near Seaside Avenue, with a 2025 sale at $2.1 million.
There aren't many listings at any given moment. On November 13, 2026, Guilford had 12 active condo listings and 44 active single-family listings. With that little inventory, the month-to-month median will keep moving with whichever complexes happen to have sales, and the 2027 numbers may jump back up if a few new-build or view units close.
The biggest residential project now underway on the Route 1 corridor won't affect these figures. Guilford Village West at 1940 Boston Post Road was approved by the Planning and Zoning Commission in September 2025 for four buildings with 162 rental apartments, 20 of them affordable. Developer Robert Sachs of Cherry Hill Construction told Patch in October that work on the apartments had begun, and that he expects leasing to start in early summer 2027. Those apartments will be rentals, so they will add places to live in town without changing the condo sales data.
A Short FAQ
Did Guilford condos lose a third of their value in 2026? The figures don't show that. The 32.9% drop compares January through October 2026 with the same months of 2025, and the 2025 group included a $5.45 million penthouse, a $2.1 million new townhouse and new-build sales in the $800,000s. In the one community where like units can be compared over time, Village on State, prices went from the low $800,000s in 2024 and 2025 to the $900,000s in 2026.
Why is October's $172,500 median so low? It is the middle of 10 sales. A handful of smaller older units can set a median that low, and SmartMLS notes that small samples produce extreme swings.
Is Guilford's condo market faster or slower than its single-family market? It is slower. From January through October 2026, condos averaged 82 days to sell and houses averaged 29, and condo buyers generally paid at or below asking.
If you're comparing Guilford condos with those in other Shoreline towns and want sales figures for one specific complex, Cathy Lynch & Team can go through recent closings with you unit by unit, so the price you weigh comes from homes like the one you're considering. Schedule a no-pressure consultation with a Shoreline expert, or take a look at our Guilford neighborhood page.