Madison's second survey on the Surf Club concept plan closes Sunday, October 18, 2026, at 11:59 p.m. Residents get one response each, either online or on a paper copy from the library, the Senior Center or the Surf Club. The survey opens with general park improvements, including a list of optional amenities like a splash pad, a pavilion and connected paths. Then it turns to the beach. According to the survey text, the beach "has lost more than half of its size since the 1930s, and recent winter storms have accelerated its erosion."
The beach and seawall questions set the limits for the building questions that follow them. The way the town handles the shoreline affects where a building can safely sit, and where it sits affects how large it can be and what it can hold.
A Wall That Needs Short-Term Repairs
The Surf Club has two seawalls in very different shape. The Garvan Point seawall was rebuilt in 2024, and the town says it "is now adequately protecting the picnic areas." The older wall in front of the playground and main building "has reached the end of its functional life and is becoming unstable," and the town says it will need more repairs in the short term just to stay standing.
The long-term question is what kind of edge the park should have after that. Assuming the options are viable and cost about the same, the survey offers three:
- Sand dunes with plantings up to 4 feet high, plus beach nourishment
- A larger fortified seawall, plus beach nourishment
- Stabilizing the existing wall and doing nothing further
A separate question covers the beach itself. The choices are doing nothing, a stone jetty or breakwater (the survey calls this the most expensive option, with difficult permitting), a smaller stone sill closer to shore, or a "living shoreline" made of dune restoration, added sand and a submerged reef.
The preliminary concept from Kent+Frost Landscape Architects favors the nature-based approach. It leaves the newer Garvan Point wall alone and proposes replacing the deteriorating older wall with dunes and nourished beach. It does not rebuild that wall as it stands today. The plan's beach section breaks the shoreline into zones. Nourishment and dune restoration would run along the beach, and living breakwaters, reef balls and possibly engineered structures would go in the central zone.
There was once much more beach to protect. At a May Board of Selectmen meeting, Chad Frost of Kent+Frost said, "Historically, there was over 140 feet of beach from the wall out to the waterline. Currently, we don't have anywhere near that," according to Zip06. Zip06 also reported that Selectman Scott Murphy said "one of the paramount guidelines" for any project is keeping the views of Long Island Sound. Dunes capped at 4 feet fit that guideline better than a taller wall would.
The $600,000 Ceiling on the Current Building
The beach question leads straight to the building. According to the survey, the current Surf Club building sits in a FEMA AE flood zone and partly inside a VE zone. The VE zone is the high-velocity wave area, where major storms can bring waves of 3 feet or higher. Under FEMA rules, the town can't make substantial improvements worth more than 50% of the structure's value unless it meets all FEMA requirements. The survey puts that ceiling at about $600,000 for this building. It also says the current list of building needs "is expected to exceed $600K."
That's why the building question offers four paths: keep the status quo and replace the building only if a storm destroys it, make limited repairs up to the FEMA cap, elevate the building where it stands at substantial cost, or build new outside the flood and wave zones, also at substantial cost. First Selectwoman Peggy Lyons was blunt about it in May. "The reality is that building is going to be demolished," she said, adding that public feedback showed "it just makes more sense to tear the building down and then rebuild something in a new location," Zip06 reported.
The concept puts a new building in the middle of the beachfront park, positioned "to maximize views of Long Island Sound," with a deck overlook and a Snack Shack next to it with shaded seating. Garvan Point would get a pavilion and event lawn rather than the building.
What a Bigger Building Changes
Moving the building opens up room, and that's where the size questions come in.
| Existing Surf Club | Preliminary concept | |
|---|---|---|
| Building size | About 5,550 sq ft | 10,785 sq ft one-story or 13,720 sq ft two-story |
| Indoor event capacity | Up to 75 people, 120 using the outdoor deck | Up to 150 people indoors |
| Program and event space | One shared room | Separate rooms |
| Snack bar | Existing concession | New Snack Shack beside the building |
Today, Beach & Recreation year-round programs and summer camps share one indoor room with weddings, parties, meetings and fundraisers. The survey's capacity figure for the existing building, 120 people with the deck, depends on weather the town itself calls a vulnerability. Residents can choose a 75-person room, a room for up to 150, or no event space at all. They can also pick building amenities, including air conditioning, bigger bathrooms, changing rooms separate from the bathrooms, a better kitchen, improved accessibility and an indoor restaurant or snack bar.
The snack bar question is the most detailed one on the survey. It offers replacing and relocating it outside the wave zone, expanding it, keeping it the same size, keeping it the same size in the same place, or demolishing it without a replacement.
How the Beach Plan Reaches Strong Field and Exchange Field
The changes reach well beyond the sand. The concept realigns and expands parking near Strong Field, a change the plan says "creates additional space for the beach front park." Strong Field stays as it is. Kent+Frost studied traffic on game days and on the Fourth of July and proposes a gateway roundabout, a drop-off area, raised crosswalks and a separated bike lane.
Up the hill, Exchange Field gets a new access drive through the woodland, expanded parking, a drop-off area, reorganized baseball, softball and practice fields, a new playground and a multi-purpose facilities building. The town says the plan adds 80 parking spaces overall, with most of the new ones near the upper fields for sports traffic. A new Surf Club Drive connection to Route 1 "is intented to only be used for larger events, and not a daily use entrance." The plan also adds a woodland amphitheater and a wetland park for residents and town camps.
An accessible path would run from the park entrance past the Surf Club to Garvan Point, linking picnic areas, a playground, the splash pad, the pavilion and the event lawn. The basketball courts would be grouped together near the beach. On the optional list, the survey asks which of these residents would keep: the pavilion, the splash pad, the connected paths, parking and bathrooms at the upper fields, and a secondary exit onto Boston Post Road.
What Hasn't Been Priced
The public materials reviewed for this post show no price for any of it. At a Beach and Recreation Commission meeting in July, department head Austin Hall said costs had not been estimated and that permitting would affect the timeline, Patch reported. The survey notes that each beach option could become a capital project needing state permits, and that the town plans to bring in a coastal engineer to evaluate them. Lyons repeated that plan in a September letter in Zip06.
The packet's own schedule shows how the survey fits in:
- Continued public feedback on the concept plan, summer 2026
- A revised design development plan, with more public input, fall 2026
- A cost estimate with a possible phasing plan, fall 2026
- A final Surf Club master plan, fall/winter 2026
The revised design and the cost estimate are both scheduled for this fall, the same season the survey closes, and the town has said more public outreach will follow.
The full informational packet, a recording of the June 10 session at Neck River Elementary and earlier reports are on the town's Surf Club Master Plan page. You can take the survey online until Sunday night, and you can email questions to [email protected].
At Cathy Lynch & Team, we follow plans like this one because the Surf Club is part of daily life in Madison. If you want to talk about how the town's long-term plans for its public spaces fit into your own plans here, schedule a no-pressure consultation with a Shoreline expert.
This article is general information, not legal, tax or financial advice. Consult a qualified professional about your situation.